Recommendations listed by year of first publication:
2010s
2015 – The Muses of Shuyedan-18 by Indrapramit Das
2014 – Ill Met in Tanivar by Reyna Todd
2014 – A Word Shaped Like Bones by Kris Millering
2013 – This Villain You Must Create by Carlie St. George
2013 – When Dickens met Dostoevsky by Eric Naiman
2013 – Spar (The Bacon Remix) by Kij Johnson
2013 – Trans-Siberia: An Account of a Journey by Sarah Brooks
2012 – Notes from the Apocalypse by Stephen Graham Jones
2012 – A Tall Tail by Charles Stross
2012 – The Bathtub by Robert Shearman
2012 – Blessed by Helen Marshall
2011 – Six Months, Three Days by Charlie Jane Anders
2010 – Alone by Robert Reed
2010 – Nothing Personal by Richard A. Lupoff
2000s
2009 – Monkey Suit by Alastair Reynolds
2009 – Mongoose by Sarah Monette & Elizabeth Bear
2009 – Spar by Kij Johnson
2009 – Toll Booth by Michael Aronovitz
2008 – The Tear by Ian McDonald
2008 – The Fantasy Jumper by Will McIntosh
2008 – The Gutter Sees the Light that Never Shines by Alistair Rennie
2008 – Snatch Me Another by Mercurio D. Rivera
2008 – The Ray-Gun: A Love Story by James Alan Gardner
2008 – 26 Monkeys, Also the Abyss by Kij Johnson
2007 – The Cambist and Lord Iron: a Fairy Tale of Economics by Daniel Abraham
2007 – MetaPhysics by Elizabeth M. Glover
2007 – Capture, Courting and Copulation: Contemporary Human Mating Rituals and the Etiology of Human Agression by Carolyn Vakesh and Steve Vakesh
2006 – I Hold My Father’s Paws by David D. Levine
2006 – …With By Good Intentions by Carrie Richerson
2006 – Yellow Card Man by Paolo Bacigalupi
2006 – The Pacific Mystery by Stephen Baxter
2006 – What This Story Needs is a Giant Gorilla by Darrell Schweitzer
2005 – Separations by Jean-Claude Dunyach
2004 – Cosmonaut X by Arthur Wyatt and Laurence Campbell
2004 – Creating the Innocent Killer by John Kessel
2004 – Abraham’s Boys by Joe Hill
2003 – Just Like the Ones We Used to Know by Connie Willis
2003 – What’s Up Tiger Lily by Paul di Filippo
2003 – Esther Gordon Framlingham by Anthony Mann
2003 – Happier Days by Jan Lars Jensen
2003 – Red Meat by Elaine Viets
2003 – The Bottle: A Provincial Tale by Charlotte Hobson
2003 – Wenceslas Square by Arthur Phillips
2003 – Catskin by Kelly Link
2002 – Shylock on the Neva by Gary Schteyngart
2002 – Baby Doll by Johanna Sinisalo
2002 – Standing Water by Caitlin R. Kiernan
2001 – Senator Bilbo by Andy Duncan
2000 – Dead Like Me by Adam Troy-Castro
2000 – 93990 by George Saunders
1990s
1999 – Flashman and the Tiger by George MacDonald Fraser
1998 – Three Miles Down by James Hamilton-Peterson
1997 – London Bone by Michael Moorcock
1997 – The Nostalginauts by S.N. Dyer
1996 – The Goldfish Pool and Other Stories by Neil Gaiman
1996 – The Soul Selects Her Own Society by Connie Willis
1996 – The Green Arches by Joan Aiken
1995 – Professor Gottesman and the Indian Rhinoceros by Peter S. Beagle
1995 – Explorations by Robert D. Ballard and Malcolm McConnell
1994 – The Tourist by Paul Park
1994 – The Ocean and All Its Devices by William Browning Spencer
1996 – Tattercoats by Midori Synder
1993 – Disneyland with the Death Penalty by William Gibson
1992 – The Midlist Bombers by Charles Stross
1993 – The Case of the Skinflint’s Specters by Brian M. Thomsen
1992 – Eternally Yours by Joy Williams
1992 – Graves by Joe Haldeman
1991 – Turpentine by Marry N. Malzberg
1991 – Water Bringer by Mary Rosenblum
1991 – Big Game by T.C. Boyle
1991 – Understand by Ted Chiang
1990 – Bears Discover Fire by Terry Bisson
1990 – Negative Reinforcement by Chuck Palahniuk
1980s
1989 – A Birch Tree, A White Fox by Elena Arsenieva
1989 – Nicholas Was by Neil Gaiman
1989 – The Adder by Fred Chappell
1989 – Too Many Crooks by Donald E. Westlake
1988 – A Critical Commentary of the Necronomicon by Robert M. Price
1988 – The Player of Games part 1 and part 2 by Iain M. Banks
1988 – The Last Article by Harry Turtledove
1987 – Flowers of Edo by Bruce Sterling
1985 – The Carpetmaker’s Son by Andreas Eschbach
1985 – Writ in Water, or the Gingerbread Man by Avram Davidson
1985 – Portraits of his Children by George R.R. Martin
1984 – Mrs. Todd’s Shortcut by Stephen King
1984 – The Crystal Spheres by David Brin
1984 – Rawhead Rex by Clive Barker
1982 – The Malaysian Mer by Jane Yolen
1981 – The Only Death in the City by C.J. Cherryh
1970s
1977 – Ender’s Game by Orson Scott Card
1976 – The Tugging by Ramsey Campbell
1975 – Somehow, I Don’t Think We’re in Kansas Anymore, Toto by Harlan Ellison
1973 – Two Sadnesses by George Alec Effinger
1972 – Nobody’s Home by Joanna Russ
1971 – Reunion by Arthur C. Clarke
1960s
1967 – A Toy for Juliette by Robert Bloch
1967 – The Prowler in the City at the Edge of the World by Harlan Ellison
1967 – The Billiard Ball by Isaac Asimov
1964 – Touchstone by Terry Carr
1962 – The Streets of Ashkelon by Harry Harrison
1950s
1959 – Lean Times in Lankhmar by Fritz Leiber
1958 – The Hated by Frederik Pohl
1958 – The Distributor by Richard Matheson
1958 – Aristotle and the Gun by L. Sprague de Camp
1958 – Theory of Rocketry by C.M Kornbluth
1956 – The Bound Man by Ilse Aichinger
1953 – Disappearing Act by Richard Matheson
1952 – The Adventure of the Wax Gamblers by Adrian Conan Doyle & John Dickson Carr
1951 – Fool’s Mate by Stanley Ellin
1950 – Punishment Without Crime by Ray Bradbury
1950 – The Magic Chalk by Abe Kobo
1950 – A Note for the Milkman by Sidney Carroll
1940s
1949 – Got a Letter from Jimmy by Shirley Jackson
1948 – Man from the South by Roald Dahl
1948 – The Specialty of the House by Stanley Ellin
1947 – The Immortal by Jorge Luis Borges
1947 – All But Empty by Graham Greene
1944 – The Long Sheet by William Sansom
1942 – The Macbeth Murder Mystery by James Thurber
1942 – Settler’s Wall by Robert A.W. Lowndes
1941 – The Standard of Living by Dorothy Parker
1941 – But Our Hero Was Not Dead by Manly Wade Wellman
1930s
1939 – Trouble with Water by Horace L. Gold
1936 – Wine on the Desert by Max Brand
1934 – The Three Marked Pennies by Mary Elizabeth Counselman
1930 – Let’s Play King by Sinclair Lewis
1930 – Tokay of the Comet Year by H. Warner Allen
1920s
1929 – The Little House at Croix-Rousse by Georges Simenon
1928 – Rope by Katherine Anne Porter
1926 – The Music from Behind the Moon by James Branch Cabell
1924 – The Rats in the Walls by H.P. Lovecraft
1922 – Winter Dreams by F. Scott Fitzgerald
1922 – Scoring Off Jeeves by P.G. Wodehouse
1910s
1913 – The Horror of the Heights by Arthur Conan Doyle
1900s
1908 – The Screaming Skull by F. Marion Crawford
1908 – The Fortress Unvanquishable, Save for Sacnoth by Lord Dunsany
1905 – The Weight of Obligation by Rex Beach
1890s
1897 – A Pair of Stockings by Kate Chopin
1894 – The Great God Pan by Arthur Machen
1892 – The Yellow Wall-Paper by Charlotte Perkins Gilman
1856 – Silly Novels by Lady Novelists by George Eliot
BCE
440BCE (approximate) – The Thief versus King Rhampsinitus by Herodotus